Tybee Island, GA
4 Bedrooms, 3 Baths, Sleeps 13
Tybee Island, GA
This circa 1920 beach cottage is perfect for big families traveling on a budget. Are you looking for a true Tybee experience? If you want to spend your time exploring the beach and have an inexpensive place to sleep and relax afterwards, this may be what you are looking for. Cute, beachy, authentic Tybee feel. Downstairs has a living room that doubles as a sleeping space with 2 twin beds. There is one bedroom downstairs with a queen bed as well. The kitchen has been updated and is fully furnished. There is one bathroom downstairs that has a tub/shower combo. The back of the house has a wonderful screened porch with a TV and lots of seating and is a great place for everyone to gather after enjoying the day at the beach. The upstairs is only accessible for the outside stairway. There is no interior access to the upstairs. Upstairs has a sitting area. There is a full bath off the sitting area that has a tub/shower combo. One upstairs bedroom has a queen bed and TV with DVD player. The 2nd upstairs bedroom has 2 twin beds. The two bedrooms are separated by a jack-n-jill bathroom with a walk-in shower. The third bedroom we call the bunk room with 5 twin beds and TV. Ready for your Tybee vacation getaway!
- BBQ Grill
- Cable TV
- Ceiling Fans
- Central Air
- Close to Town
- Coffee Maker
- Full Kitchen
- Ice Maker
- Near Beach
- Nearby ATM
- Nearby Grocery
- Nearby Medical Services
- Nearby Post Office
- Washer & Dryer
Reviews Write a Review
Average Manager Rating (Based on 369 reviews)
Average Vacation Rental Rating (Based on 29 reviews)
100% of our reviewers would recommend this vacation rental.
Great House for Girl Scouts
Stayed 3 days in June, 2017
Jennifer J. from Wylie, TX recommends this vacation rental.
My Girl Scout Troop wanted a few days on the beach before heading to Savannah. This house was the perfect size for us. Lots of beds, a great screened in porch and just a small walk to the beach. The only thing we thought we were going to have was a DVD players. Though that didn't stop us grin having a good time. Thanks so much!!
Manager Responded on 07/13/2017
J~ The Conoly Cottage is always a favorite for the Girl Scouts! I hope you enjoyed Tybee and Savannah and that you will stay with us again on your next trip. ~TTVR
The Perfect Weekend
Stayed 3 days in May, 2017
Chandler G. from Blairsville, GA recommends this vacation rental.
Manager Responded on 06/14/2017
Very Clean and Comfortable Accomodations
Stayed 3 days in April, 2017
David W. from Gainesville, GA recommends this vacation rental.
The pictures are deceiving. We thought the house was better than the pictures showed. The house was old, but very clean and very well decorated. A very nice house and we would stay there again. Very convenient location. The layout of the house forces congregation onto the screened porch, which was a very nice gathering place.
Manager Responded on 04/18/2017
D~ So glad that you and your family liked Conoly Cottage. Maybe we need some better pictures! We hope you will book with us again if you get the chance to take some more Tybee Time. ~TTVR
Stayed 4 days in March, 2017
A guest from Dahlonega, GA recommends this vacation rental.
A very unique quaint cottage near the beach. The highlight of this house is the spacious screened porch. Everything you need for you beach trip (chairs, boogie boards, etc.) is there for use. House was spotless. Great job housekeeping! The only down side was having to use the outside stairs for the bedrooms upstairs. But this was not a surprise since the description indicates this situation.
Manager Responded on 04/06/2017
J~ Sounds like the Conoly Cottage worked out great for your family. Thanks for taking time to submit a review. Next time you have a break, head our way! ~TTVR
Quaint cottage with loads of character
Stayed 5 days in March, 2017
Julie D. from Chattanooga, TN recommends this vacation rental.
Loved the cottage!
Manager Responded on 03/26/2017
Thanks J~ Let us know when you can come back for more Tybee Time! ~TTVR
Great weekend trip
Stayed 3 days in August, 2016
Kristine F. from Dayton, OH recommends this vacation rental.
Home was as described. Lots of space to spread out. Only item not elaborated on was the fact that the "upstairs" bedroom/bath area could only be accessed from an outside staircase.
Stayed 3 days in September, 2016
A guest from Charlotte, NC recommends this vacation rental.
This house was perfect for our bachelorette weekend! So much space and five minute walk to the beach! The drive into Savannah was fast too! Overall my stay here was amazing!
Manager Responded on 10/26/2016
L~ So glad that you all enjoyed the Conoly Cottage! Maybe this will become an annual event to get together with friends? Just let us know if we can help coordinate more Tybee Time! ~TTVR
Tybee girls weekend
Stayed 3 days in September, 2016
Margaret S. from Brunswick, GA recommends this vacation rental.
We had a wonderful stay on Tybee. The house was perfect for us and the rents company also. We were coming in on the midst of a small hurricane but the rental company made sure the house was in good shape and the yard even got cleaned up. The weather turned out sunny and the weekend was great.
Manager Responded on 09/23/2016
M~ We were lucky that the weather after the storm was so beautiful. I am glad that the Conoly Cottage suited your needs and we would love to have you book with us again! ~TTVR
Stayed 5 days in August, 2016
Tammy M. from Mauldin, SC recommends this vacation rental.
It was wonderful! We enjoyed the house and it is in a great location.
Manager Responded on 08/26/2016
T~ Thank you! Please contact us if you can squeeze in some more Tybee Time at the Conoly Cottage! ~TTVR
A Cottage with Character
Stayed 4 days in August, 2016
Fran C. from Alto, GA recommends this vacation rental.
Great stay on Tybee! We have many children ranging in age from 6 to 24 and my parents and everyone was comfortable at this old but quaint cottage by the sea. The walk to the beach was easy as was the distance to the grocery store and food places. The screened in porch was the hit of our whole group. Loved it! We will visit again and recommend to others.
Manager Responded on 08/17/2016
F~ Thank you so much for the review. Glad that the Conoly Cottage worked out for you and your family! We will be looking forward to your return visit. ~TTVR
Stayed 7 days in July, 2016
Stacy T. from Velpen, IN recommends this vacation rental.
Nice place to stay. Enjoyed being close to the beach and within walking distance from everything else. Had a problem with drain in the kitchen and it was fixed in no time!
Manager Responded on 07/21/2016
S~ Thanks for the review. And we are always glad when our guests enjoy their stay. Sounds like the Conoly Cottage worked well for your group and we hope you were able to enjoy some quality Tybee Time while you were here. ~TTVR
Stayed 7 days in June, 2016
David B. from Inman, SC recommends this vacation rental.
We had a great time. The house had plenty of room, even for the 5 grandsons. The huge screen porch w/TV was the greatest feature of this house. The really short walk to the beach made it convenient.<br/>The upstairs porch railing needs some attention, but did not hamper our visit.<br/>Under the upper porch is a great storage place for beach chairs, pop-up tents, umbrellas, etc.<br/>An outside shower would be a great addition!<br/>Old gas grill would not light. We had to remove the grates and light it manually.
Manager Responded on 07/15/2016
D~ Thanks for taking the time to review your stay at Conoly Cottage. And we will pass along the comments and suggestions to the owners. We are glad that the whole family enjoyed their Tybee Time! ~TTVR
Stayed 4 days in May, 2016
A guest from Devils Lake, ND recommends this vacation rental.
This cottage was great for out group of 12. There were enough showers to accommodate all of us. We would recommend this cottage for a large group. The beach was close enough to walk to.
Manager Responded on 06/14/2016
J~ Glad that the Conoly Cottage worked out well for your group! Please let us know if we can ever help you with a repeat visit to the island! ~~TTVR
Great Tybee Experience
Stayed 3 days in May, 2016
Russell N. from Blythe, GA recommends this vacation rental.
Conoly Cottage is a great cottage. My group was family and friends. There was plenty of room for all of us to relax. The property is in a convienient location. It is well cared for, especially for a house that is nearing 100 years old. Having three bathrooms was a plus for a large group. I would definately stay there again, and reccomend it to friends. The managment staff was courteous and quick to respond to communications.
Manager Responded on 06/12/2016
R~ Thank you for taking the time to review your stay at Conoly Cottage. I'm glad that it worked out well for your family and friends. Please let us know if we can ever help you on a future stay! ~TTVR
Perfect Place for Us
Stayed 6 days in May, 2016
james h. from Cornelius, NC recommends this vacation rental.
We really enjoyed our time on Tybee, and particularly our time in Conoly Cottage. It was just the perfect place for us.
Manager Responded on 05/11/2016
J~ Glad you enjoyed your stay in Conoly Cottage! Thanks for the heads up on a couple of maintenance issues. We look forward to your return visit in the fall! ~TTVR
Stayed 4 days in March, 2016
Amy V. from Forked River, NJ recommends this vacation rental.
We had a great time. House had to tons of beds. It was a great weekend. The only negative is, there was not enough garbage bags and toilet paper for the amount of people and the amount of time.
Manager Responded on 04/09/2016
A~ Glad that you and your group enjoyed your stay at the Conoly Cottage. Sorry, but there is no way for us to judge how much supplies each group will need... that's why we just provide a start-up supply of 2 rolls of toilet paper per bathroom and 3 garbage bags. ~TTVR
Stayed 4 days in March, 2016
A guest from CHATTANOOGA, TN recommends this vacation rental.
I visited Tybee recently for a March holiday. And had a great time and stay. The accommodations were excellent and had every thing we needed.(except food). Super convenient to local attractions. I appreciate the communication the agent interacted with me with as well.
Manager Responded on 03/24/2016
RJJ~ Thanks for taking the time to post your comments... Glad you had a great stay! Sad that I got 4 out of 5 stars :( I'll try and do better next time!? ~TTVR
Stayed 3 days in November, 2015
Rhonda B. from Cumming, GA recommends this vacation rental.
The Conoly Cottage was perfect! There were 9 of us and we had plenty of room to move. We loved the screened in porch- spent a lot of time out there. Our walk to the beach was short and we could even walk down to the grocery store. The rental process was easy and each one of us agreed that we would stay again! <br/>The only issue, not really an issue, but the big screen tv on the porch did not work. It would have been nice early in the morning to catch the news.
Manager Responded on 11/11/2015
R~ Glad you enjoyed your stay at Conoly Cottage. Sorry to hear that you had an issue with the TV on the porch. I will let the owners know. In the future, if you stay with us again, please let us know anytime there is an issue. Most of the time we can get it resolved while you are there. Come back soon! ~TTVR
Stayed 4 days in October, 2015
Elaine E. from Royston, Ga recommends this vacation rental.
We enjoyed our time at Tybee. We liked the house, just a few issues. Every time we did a laundry, water backed up into both kitchen sinks. One of the steps on back porch is lose, we had to be careful not to fall. The tv on porch doesn't work. But overall we enjoyed our stay.
Manager Responded on 10/25/2015
E~ Thanks for staying with us! We have passed the maintenance comments on to the owners for their attention. Unfortunately, the TV on the porch was just a loose cable connection... wish you would have called me and I could have taken care of that for you. Come back for more Tybee Time soon! ~TTVR
Stayed 4 days in August, 2015
Beverly P. from Riverdale, GA recommends this vacation rental.
I really enjoyed my stay at the conoly cottage would definitely recommend to friends and family thanks for the experience!
Manager Responded on 09/26/2015
B~ Glad you enjoyed your stay! I will send you a private message about your concerns on cleanliness and see what we can do to address those. We hope to have you back on your next visit to Tybee Island. ~TTVR
Family vacation of 14
Stayed 7 days in June, 2015
A guest from Woodbury, TN recommends this vacation rental.
We enjoyed our stay and the management was very kind. We are planning another trip in October.
Manager Responded on 09/22/2015
S~ Thanks! I hope we have something that will work for you in October! ~TTVR
Conoly Cottage was wonderful!
Stayed 4 days in August, 2015
A guest from Thomasville, GA recommends this vacation rental.
This house was absolutley perfect for what we needed! The house was very cute, we loved the seperation of the upstairs and downstairs! The decorations were beachy but not too overwhelming! The back porch was our favorite spot to where we all could fit comfortably in one room! The bathrooms were very nice and updated along with nice plush towels! Beds were extremely comfortable upstairs and downstairs! Very close to everything! Was a great price for what we were offered! Needless to say if we ever need a place to stay on Tybee again we will be revisting the Conoly Cottage! Thank you so much for such a wonderful stay!
Manager Responded on 08/15/2015
A~ Thanks for the great review. We are glad that you and your friends enjoyed the home. Hopefully you will be able to visit the island again and will let us help you book accommodations. We love repeat guests! ~TTVR
Quiet & Spacious spot on the island
Stayed 3 days in May, 2015
Peggy C. from Charlotte, NC recommends this vacation rental.
My group had a great stay at Conoly Cottage. The booking process was super easy. Plenty of space for 12 grown-ups (lots of single beds!). Location is great - easy walk to the beach, away from the crowded spots such as the pier (you can still work to the "downtown" district, OR drive). Best part of the house: the porch (I slept there 2 nights out of 3)!
Manager Responded on 05/29/2015
P~ We are glad that you all loved the Conoly Cottage... and that screened porch is hard to beat! Come back for more Tybee Time... and bring some friends! ~TTVR
Stayed 7 days in July, 2014
Valinda J. from Tullahoma, TN recommends this vacation rental.
The property was a short walk to the beach. Very nice. <br/>The house was clean but could have used a few more entry rugs to slow down the down and mud....a lot of rainy nights.<br/>The customer service was excellent! I had questions and was tended to quickly. <br/>I would recommend this property to friends.<br/>We enjoyed the neighborhood, not very congested with traffic. We road on the bar bike one evening...very fun. Went into savannah for an afternoon tour. Ate at DJs and Crab Shack, both very good. Loved the atmosphere of Tybee, very laid back and country comfy not to commercialized.
Manager Responded on 08/01/2014
V~ Thanks for taking time to review Conoly Cottage. We are glad that the home worked well for your group. Sorry about the rainy nights... weather is one of those things we can't control. We will forward the rug suggestion to the owners. We hope that you will be back on Tybee for a return visit soon! ~TTVR
Comfort and Convenience
Stayed 7 days in July, 2014
A guest from Pittsburgh, PA recommends this vacation rental.
We stayed at Conolly Cottage from July 5-12, 2014. We found the accommodations to be better than we expected- don't think the pics do it justice. The decorating is cute and beach appropriate. There was plenty of space for our group of 14 to be comfortable. All was clean and in working order. Screened in porch was great gathering place. Please note that 1st and 2nd floors are connected by an outside staircase. We knew this before we arrived, of course. Functionally, this presented a couple minor issues. First- you need an umbrella to get from floor to floor when it rains. Second- it does give the feeling if being in 2 separate houses to those who stay on the first floor and those who stay in the second- or maybe it was just us? Like I said- nothing major!! Close to beach if you go thru the backyard and up 8th St. All around-a great, affordable place to stay!!
Manager Responded on 07/16/2014
B~ Thanks for the nice review. We are glad that you and your family had a nice time on Tybee and enjoyed staying at the Conoly Cottage. Please come back to visit again! ~TTVR
Great for our big group!!!
Stayed 3 days in May, 2014
A guest from Hoschton, Ga recommends this vacation rental.
We loved Conoly Cottage! It was great for a quick large family get way! It was walking distance to the beach. It had everything you needed! Completely stocked! Would definitely go back!!
Manager Responded on 05/29/2014
T~ Glad that you and your family had a great time on Tybee and that the Conoly Cottage fits your needs. Let us know if we can help on a future visit! ~TTVR
vacation house 2014
Stayed 6 days in April, 2014
Toshua B. from Smyrna, TN recommends this vacation rental.
We had a wonderful time. The house was great the beds were all comfortable except one. The down stairs pull out queen sofa was horrible. You felt the bars and sunk in. It could be replaced along with the floor in that room. However with saying that we would still stay there again. The porch was great for hanging out. It has more room than it stated and it was great. Just fix the downstairs sofa bed.
Manager Responded on 05/06/2014
T~ Thanks for the heads up on the sleeper sofa. We have taken that out of the advertisement. Hopefully it can be replaced soon. The flooring in that front room is slated for renovation in August... that is as soon as we can get someone in to do the work as the home is booked pretty solid until then. We would love to have you back again next year to enjoy the upgrades. ~TTVR
Christmas on Tybee
Stayed 4 days in December, 2013
Robin H. from Milledgeville, GA recommends this vacation rental.
The whole family loved the cottage and the beach. It made our holiday a happy one!
Manager Responded on 12/29/2013
So glad you and your family had a great stay on Tybee! Come back to see us soon!
Just right for a big group!
Stayed 3 days in November, 2013
Travis N. from Fletcher, NC recommends this vacation rental.
We had a fantastic stay and we had more than enough beds for our large group. Great location and very cozy, we would certainly stay there again.
Manager Responded on 12/29/2013
We are glad you enjoyed your stay at the Conoly Cottage. Come back soon for more 'Tybee Time'!